The tale of two Speakers: From the Bahamas to Jamaica two parliaments with the same problem

In the Bahamas and Jamaica, the parliamentary drama has taken on a familiar cast. Opposition members are challenging rulings, speakers are defending their authority, accusations of unfairness circulating, and the person keeping order is also becoming part of the disorder.

Patricia Deveaux and Juliet Holness occupy different parliamentary chambers, but their controversies raise a strikingly similar question about impartiality.

In the Bahamas, Patricia Deveaux has spent much of her speakership navigating confrontations with Opposition MPs. In December 2024, a dispute over whether Opposition Leader Michael Pintard could address the House escalated into extraordinary disorder, culminating in FNM MP for St Barnabas Shanendon Cartwright throwing the ceremonial mace through a window. Cartwright was responsible for that act, but the confrontation exposed the strained relationship between the chair and the Opposition.

There were further clashes in June 2026, including a public dispute with Pintard over the Public Accounts Committee. Then, last week, Long Island MP Andre Rollins was ordered out following an argument over Opposition Question Time. Rollins called Deveaux a “damn disgrace”, words he subsequently apologised for. Deveaux, for her part, acknowledged that her previous approach had been “toxic” and said she intended to follow parliamentary procedure.

Across the Caribbean, in Kingston, Juliet Holness is confronting a different but overlapping controversy.

Her position carries an unusual political complication since she is married to Prime Minister Andrew Holness, whose Government she presides over in Parliament. The Opposition People’s National Party has repeatedly questioned whether that relationship compromises public confidence in her independence, calling for an independent Speaker.

But the criticism has gone beyond her marriage. Opposition members have challenged her rulings, her handling of debate and what they describe as restrictions on their ability to scrutinise the Government. On November 3, a debate over a motion censuring the Government’s position on Cuba ended in disorder, with competing allegations about what happened after the sitting. Holness says Opposition MP Angela Brown Burke pushed her; Brown Burke denies doing so.

The Opposition subsequently introduced a censure motion against Holness, accusing her of making an unsupported assault allegation and citing other complaints about her conduct. Holness rejects the suggestion that her marriage compromises her independence. She says she was duly elected in her own right and will not be intimidated into abandoning her responsibilities.

It was against this backdrop that Deveaux publicly defended her Jamaican counterpart, arguing that Holness should be judged by her decisions and integrity, not by her marriage. She later apologised for remarks interpreted as interference in Jamaica’s internal affairs.

Yet her argument raises a question that neither island can comfortably avoid.

A Speaker’s impartiality cannot be established by political affiliation alone, nor disproved by marriage. It must be demonstrated in the everyday business of Parliament: who gets heard, how rules are applied, how disagreement is handled and whether the chair protects the rights of members on both sides.

The Speaker is not expected to be everyone’s favourite person in Parliament, but she is expected to be everyone’s Speaker.

The office requires the confidence of those who disagree with you. Though Deveaux and Holness control the proceedings, the credibility of the chair depends on whether both sides in the House believe they are being treated fairly.

Show More
Leave a Reply