fnm

South Beach has developed a reputation as a flip-flopping constituency in Bahamian politics.

Unlike traditional strongholds, South Beach has consistently shifted between the Progressive Liberal Party and the Free National Movement over successive election cycles, making it a key battleground heading into May 12.

The current race features incumbent Bacchus Rolle for the PLP, facing Darren Henfield for the FNM and Karon Farrington representing the Coalition of Independents.

In 2021, Rolle secured the seat with 1,959 votes, defeating the FNM’s Jeffrey Lloyd, who received 1,296 votes. The Coalition of Independents candidate earned 322 votes.

South Beach’s voting history suggests that such leads are not permanent.

Over the past four election cycles, the seat has alternated between parties: Cleola Hamilton (PLP) in 2012, Lloyd (FNM) in 2017, and now Rolle (PLP) in 2021. Earlier, Phenton Neymour held the seat for the FNM in 2007.

This shows that South Beach voters are willing to shift their support, often in response to national mood, candidate appeal, and local concerns.

Rolle enters the race with the advantage of incumbency.

However, Henfield is not an unknown challenger. As a former Member of Parliament for North Abaco, he has experience and name recognition, factors that could help consolidate FNM support.

While Farrington is new to frontline politics, her presence reflects a broader sentiment among some voters who are increasingly open to alternatives outside the two major parties. Historically, third-party candidates have struggled to win seats, but they can influence the result by drawing votes away from traditional party bases.

Still, the race remains between the PLP and the FNM.

The Free National Movement campaign launch over the weekend felt different, not just in energy, but in intention.

Held at Baha Mar, the event was polished, tightly organised, and notably disciplined. But beyond the visuals and excitement, it carried something political events often struggle to balance—substance.

At its core, the launch appeared to be a deliberate attempt to reach beyond the party’s base, targeting undecided voters, disengaged citizens, and those increasingly disillusioned with traditional politics. And for many watching, it landed as a message of cautious hope.

Watch FNM Campaign Launch here

Michael Pintard, leading from the front, projected control and clarity. His delivery was measured, his messaging consistent. More importantly, he avoided the trap of pure rally rhetoric.

Instead, he offered what felt like an early blueprint of governance — a window into what a Pintard administration could look like.

That distinction is critical.

In a political climate where trust is fragile, Pintard leaned heavily into accountability, even turning inward. His warning to FNM candidates that corruption would not be tolerated under his leadership, was one of the night’s defining moments. It was not just a critique of the current political environment; it was an acknowledgement of public frustration with political culture as a whole.

And it was paired with policy.

From expanding VAT exemptions on essential goods, to a promise of 5,000 affordable homes, to cutting the country’s billion-dollar food import bill in half through an “agriculture revolution,” the proposals were broad but pointed. There were also commitments to address illegal immigration with a “firm yet humane” approach, fix longstanding issues in healthcare, and restore banking access in underserved Family Island communities.

Taken together, the message was clear. The party is positioning itself as ready to govern, not just campaign.

The contrast with the current administration, led by Philip Davis, was implied throughout, particularly on issues like cost of living, governance standards, and public services. But notably, the tone avoided excessive aggression, opting instead for a more controlled, national appeal.

That, too, may be strategic.

With voter apathy still a real factor heading into 2026, Pintard’s direct appeal to those considering staying home, warning that disengagement could open the door to poor leadership, suggests the FNM understands that turnout could be just as critical as persuasion.

Marco City will be watched closely in the upcoming general election, and at the center of it is Michael Pintard.

The Free National Movement leader is seeking a third consecutive term as Member of Parliament for the Grand Bahama seat, a break from the constituency’s long-standing pattern of turnovers.

This time, the PLP has put forward Edward Whan, a businessman from Freeport, while the Coalition of Independents is represented by Jillian Bartlett. It raises familiar questions about vote splitting and whether third-party candidates can meaningfully disrupt the two-party race.

Historically, Marco City has switched between the FNM and the Progressive Liberal Party every election cycle, making sustained dominance rare.

The seat has moved from Pleasant Bridgewater (PLP) to Zhivargo Laing (FNM), then to Greg Moss (PLP), before Pintard’s back-to-back victories.

Pintard first won the seat in 2017 and held it again in 2021, where he secured 2,340 votes, comfortably ahead of PLP candidate Curt G. Hollingsworth, who received 1,359. Third-party and independent candidates, including those aligned with the Coalition of Independents, collectively drew a smaller but notable share of the vote.

Still, the focus remains on Pintard.

As both incumbent and party leader, his candidacy carries weight beyond the constituency. A third win would solidify his local political strength but also show momentum for the FNM nationally. A loss, however, would raise immediate questions about the party’s path to government.

The Free National Movement is set to officially launch its campaign this Saturday at Baha Mar, a moment that is expected to do more than energize supporters, but it must convince the wider audience that the party is ready to govern.

With a general election looming, which could be called at any time by Prime Minister Philip Davis, the timing raises the stakes. This can be viewed as a test of the party’s readiness to lead, message discipline and national appeal.

FNM Leader Michael Pintard has already signalled what is to come: A clearer picture of the party’s platform and a preview of what a Pintard administration would look like. “The question is what will be done under a Pintard administration?” he said. “We are going to answer that question to a large extent on Saturday and in the weeks that follow.”

That answer will be critical.

The FNM is expected to present its manifesto alongside its 41 ratified candidates, a full slate meant to show the party’s organization and preparedness. But beyond that, voters will be watching for substance.

Three key questions are likely to define the night: Does the FNM offer a clear, compelling plan on issues like cost of living, healthcare, crime and jobs? Do voters believe the party can deliver on its promises? Can its candidates resonate beyond party loyalists?

The challenge for the FNM is not just to excite the room, but to reach those outside, the undecided voters, sceptics, and those disillusioned with both major parties.

In that sense, the campaign launch is more about persuasion.

As Election 2026 approaches, a question is surfacing again: Are members of the Free National Movement judged more harshly in controversy than their Progressive Liberal Party counterparts?

Among some voters, the perception is clear. When allegations or associations emerge, FNM figures often face swift calls for resignation or withdrawal. PLP leaders, critics argue, are more likely to defend, dismiss or outlast controversy.

The difference lies not just in the issue but in the response.

In 2023, when Immigration Minister Keith Bell faced criticism over decisions that some said bypassed senior immigration officials, the FNM called for his resignation. At the time, PLP Chairman Fred Mitchell publicly said he advised Bell not to respond to the controversy, suggesting it would not be beneficial.

The incident showed the PLP’s instinct to contain and stand firm rather than concede ground.

The pattern is being debated again.

After the arrest of Malcolm Goodman in the United States on drug charges, some PLP voices called on the FNM to reconsider Marvin Dames’ nomination for Mt Moriah, despite Dames not being accused of wrongdoing.

Dames acknowledged a past business arrangement with Goodman but denied any knowledge of alleged criminal activity.

At the same time, Sebas Bastian’s name appeared in recently released Jeffrey Epstein-related documents referencing trafficking allegations — allegations he has denied.

There has been no internal campaign within PLP ranks demanding political distance.

Prime Minister Philip Davis publicly stood by Bastian, insisting the claims would not affect the party’s election campaign.

Davis has also publicly stood by businessman Adrian Fox, who previously faced U.S. legal trouble connected to human smuggling allegations before entering a plea to a lesser vessel-related charge.

Davis told reporters Fox was both a client and a friend. He wrote to a U.S. judge urging a lenient sentence and later said that if given the opportunity, he would do it again.

To critics, this posture signals boldness, even defiance, in the face of controversy. To supporters, it reflects loyalty and a belief in second chances.

The broader question remains: Is accountability applied consistently, or through partisan lenses?

Newly elected Member of Parliament for Golden Isles, Darron Pickstock, officially took his seat in the House of Assembly today following his by-election victory.

Sitting on the government’s backbench with members of his family in the gallery, Pickstock used his first address to express gratitude and to outline his commitment to the constituency.

“I will work hard for Golden Isles, harder than anyone has ever worked. I will be present. I will listen. And I will act,” he said.

Pickstock also pledged to support entrepreneurship in the community, promising to be “a partner, not a barrier,” and outlined his vision of “a golden future for Golden Isles” rooted in “inclusivity, equity and shared progress.”

Reflecting on his early years, Pickstock spoke about the lessons learned from hard work and perseverance.

“I packed bags, bussed tables and cleaned floors as a teen, working nights to pay for day classes. If you want a better life, you have to be prepared to put in the work,” he said. “I come from a working family, raised on modest means, but with high expectations.”

Prime Minister Philip Davis praised Pickstock’s journey, calling him a symbol of what ordinary Bahamians can achieve.

“You asked the people for a chance. Now prove them right and go beyond their expectations,” Davis said. He also hailed the by-election result as a major victory for the Progressive Liberal Party.

“PLP is an unbeatable machine, once we get rolling, we take up everything in its wake.”

Opposition Leader Michael Pintard formally congratulated Pickstock and expressed hope that Golden Isles would see meaningful transformation under his leadership.

The Free National Movement has clarified that comments made by its former chairman in the sentencing of notorious convicted felon and disgraced fashion mogul Peter Nygard do not reflect the views of their party.

Why it matters

The trial against Nygard, a permanent resident of the Bahamas, accused of 4 counts of sexual assault in a Canadian court, is wrapping up and the FNM’s former chairman Sidney Collie is one of twenty people who wrote character letters to the judge pleading for leniency.

Canadian prosecutors are seeking a 15-year sentence while Nygard’s defense attorneys are asking for two years and time served.

The big picture

Nygard, a Canadian citizen who once lived in the Bahamas and owned a multimillion-dollar clothing empire, had close ties to the Perry Christie Administration in 2012 and was a major donor to the Progressive Liberal Party.

Women in the Bahamas, Canada and the US, accused him of sexual assault. He was convicted of sexual assault against 4 women in Toronto who said he lured them to his headquarters and attacked them, dating from the 1980s until the mid-2000s. It involved three women who were in their 20s at the time and another who was 16 years old.

No charges have been filed in the Bahamas though allegations have been levied against him.

What the FNM said

Dr. Duane Sands, the National Chairman of the party emphasized the party’s dissociation from Nygard’s deeds, marking a firm stance against the actions of Nygard.

He emphasized that Collie acted in his capacity as a former attorney for Nygard, and Collie’s character reference was made in a professional context and should not be interpreted as reflecting the party’s stance.

State of Play

Nygard was charged with nine counts in New York, including sex trafficking and racketeering charges, and still faces sexual assault charges in Manitoba and Quebec, Canada.

Former Prime Minister Hubert Minnis was seen dancing awkwardly after suffering a humiliating defeat in his party’s leadership race which saw the return of Michael Pintard as leader of the Free National Movement.

Minnis attended the West End Fish Fry at Montague with former Minister of Health Renward Wells and former Bahamas Information Services Director Kevin Harris, who supported his run to regain leadership of the FNM.

With a cup of drink in hand, Minnis dances back and forth as a band plays onstage, hopping on one leg at a time and running back and forth in an open space in front of the podium. And in another instance, he grabs the waist of a woman and enthusiastically gyrates.

“There’s nothing quite like the energy and joy shared with fellow Bahamians. Celebrating unity and connection through every step,” he said in a social media post.

Pintard dealt a heavy blow to Minnis on Saturday at the party’s one-day convention, which was foreseen—456-163. Heavy hitters in the party like Former Prime Minister Hubert Ingraham, former Minister of Immigration Brent Symonette and the majority of Minnis’ former cabinet supported Pintard. In contrast, Wells, former Deputy leader Desmond Bannister and just a few others publicly threw their support behind Minnis.

Approximately 700 delegates voted.

Minnis and his supporters like Bannister caused ramblings in the party, calling for a party convention to replace Pintard, as Minnis underhandedly campaigned at association meetings. He then publicly announced his bid for leadership in May.

After claiming “unfair practices” and “skulduggery” at the convention earlier in the day, he voted but did not attend the convention’s closing ceremony later that evening. He pledged his commitment to the party and congratulated Pintard in a statement posted to social media.

Pintard, in his victory speech, acknowledged Minnis: “Let me say tonight to Dr. Hubert Minnis that this organization has benefited from your leadership when you sat in the Cabinet of Hubert Alexander Ingraham and you distinguished yourself by bringing technology to local constituency canvassing,” Pintard said.

“You played a pivotal role in introducing catastrophic health insurance. In opposition, and God knows that opposition hard, you weathered the storm and together … with no-name face-recognized FNMs we stood in solidarity and brought the system back on board, brought the establishment back on board to support Dr. Minnis.

“You made your contribution in opposition that propelled you to become prime minister of the Commonwealth of The Bahamas. For the fourth time, the Free National Movement led this country.

“It’s clear to us that there were any number of accomplishments that you’ve achieved that are noteworthy. With your permission, in the fullness of time, this organization wishes to pay tribute to you for your contribution. Thank you, Dr. Minnis.”